Posted on Leave a comment

The Beatles: “Love Me Do”. Did Ringo Play on their First Single?

The Beatles first single, "Love Me Do"
The Beatles first single "Love Me Do"
The Beatles “Love Me Do”

5TH OCTOBER 1962: THE BEATLES FIRST SINGLE IISSUED ITHE UK

After the first session with George Martin on 4th September 1962, Martin decided to bring in a session drummer. As a result, Andy White was recruited for the second session a week later.

“RINGO DIDN’T DRUM ON THE FIRST SINGLE”

Paul was convinced that Ringo didn’t play drums on the group’s first Parlophone single, “Love Me Do” – and Ringo agreed. But, history has shown that he was indeed on the UK single release. Considering that Andy White was hired to drum on the recording, there are questions. Was Ringo’s version mistakenly released on the UK single? After all, the White version of “Love Me Do” appeared on The Beatles’ debut studio album Please Please Me, the UK EP release The Beatles’ Hits, and also on their U.S. single release.

“Love Me Do” The Beatles’ first single released on 5th October 1962

WAS IT RELEASED BY MISTAKE? ANY EVIDENCE?

If the Ringo version wasn’t considered good enough after 4th September, why release that first version? Neither George Martin nor Ron Richards were sure if it was selected intentionally or not.

Releases of “Love Me Do” issued after The Beatles’ Hits on 21st September 1963 contained Andy White’s version. Why? The original master recording of Ringo’s version of “Love Me Do” destroyed or recorded over. EMI only had Andy White’s 11th September recording to use. It was the only remaining – and arguably the superior – version. When “Love Me Do” was released in the U.S. in April 1964, it was Andy White’s version that was used.

MCARTNEY NOT MCCARTNEY!

A further mistake was made when 250 promo discs of “Love Me Do” were released, misspelling Paul’s name as McArtney; something he was used to in Mersey Beat. One of these discs was sold in October 2017 for $14,757, the most expensive 7-inch single ever sold.

50TH ANNIVERSARY MISTAKE?

In a twist of fate – or was it an inside joke – when Apple decided to reissue “Love Me Do” on the 50th anniversary, they initially used Andy White’s version. They then had to quickly recall those records, so that Ringo’s version could be issued.

The final piece of evidence is one of omission. With the group’s popularity increasing, why did they not ask Ringo to re-record “Love Me Do” for the album? The conclusion is that Ringo’ version was most likely released by accident. That is not uncommon in the recording industry, even today. Nothing else really makes sense.

Excerpt from Finding the Fourth Beatle the story of the 23 drummers who put the beat into The Beatles

David Bedford

Posted on Leave a comment

Love Me Do: Beatles Drummer Disaster with George Martin

Ringo, George, John and Paul at Abbey Road

4th September 1962: Love Me Do – The Beatles at EMI Studios

September 4th marks the 59th anniversary of Ringo Starr’s first recording session with the Beatles. Having endured one disastrous ‘test’ session on June 6th (with Pete Best behind the drum kit), the Beatles, with new drummer Ringo Starr, made an attempt at recording a potential first 45rpm single with Parlophone. 

The session was once again a disaster for the Beatles’ drummer. Perhaps overly nervous, and keen to impress after Pete Best’s rejection by George Martin and his assistant Ron Richards, during the rehearsal of Please Please Me, Ringo had a rush of blood to the head.

“I was playing the bass drum and the hi-hat, and I had a tambourine in one hand and a maraca in the other, and I was hitting the cymbals as well …… trying to play all the instruments at once”.

Recording!

Ringo was susceptible to a deadly trap a studio ‘ virgin’ could fall into, namely the dreaded ‘red light syndrome’. The new recruit appears calm and collected, until suddenly the studio red light flashes on, and a voice from the control room booms – ‘RECORDING!’. All of a sudden, bowels churn, you break into a cold sweat, your mouth is dry and miraculously, your sticks turn to rubber. After all, this could be your one big chance and now you are about to ruin it for everyone. You just freeze. Once again, at the crucial moment, the Beatles’ drummer had come unstuck, and his card was marked.

“How Do You Do It?”

The Beatles soldiered on, and begrudgingly recorded Mitch Murray’s How Do You Do It, turning in a workmanlike yet professional performance. Love Me Do however, took 15 takes to record, requiring a lot of editing to create the final, coherent version. As a result, the session over-ran. A further session was scheduled exactly a week later. 

“Love Me Do” with Andy White

Love Me Do was now being recorded for the third time – such a luxury could not be tolerated, especially as this session was to last no longer than one and three-quarter hours, half the time usually allowed. The song had to be recorded professionally and swiftly. This time, Martin was taking no chances – he had booked session drummer Andy White to take Ringo’s place. White was one of the country’s top drummers, and was well aware of the demands and constraints of the recording studio environment.

A session musician would have to be able to perform perfectly and precisely with discipline, control and without error. Ringo however, was a different animal, the studio being alien to him. With a session man behind the kit, Richards knew he could rely on White to lay down the drum track with minimum fuss, and maximum results. And so it proved, White earning his £5.15s session fee with consummate ease.

Ringo on Tambourine

This remake of Love Me Do was completed with Ringo playing alongside White on tambourine, this being the easiest way to distinguish which version has Andy White on drums. It certainly has a punchier feel to it than Ringo’s version, due to the fact the rest of the band were more familiar with the song and had probably rehearsed it in preparation for their third attempt at recording it. There is a more confident, professional presentation, due mainly to the added luxury of a tambourine. 

“Love Me Do” master destroyed

Oddly, Ringo’s September 4th recording of Love Me Do was released as the Beatles’ first single, the Andy White version being included on the Please Please Me LP, and becoming the official version for all future releases – the master tape of Ringo’s version was either destroyed, or more likely recorded over. Future releases of the Ringo version (from a 1982 anniversary release onwards) were taken from a pristine copy of an original single.

Read more about the stories behind the beat of Love Me Do, Please Please Me, and all of the Beatles’ releases in Ringo Starr And The Beatles Beat, available in the Beatles Book Store.

Alex Cain

Posted on Leave a comment

The secret of ringo starr’s contribution to the beatles

Ringo Starr
Ringo Starr
Ringo Starr

Ringo Starr – the Ordinary One

To unravel the secret of the Beatles, it is helpful to visualize the four Beatles as the four corners of an album cover. The top left corner was John, the rebel. The top right corner Paul, the musical talent. The lower left corner George, the spiritual one, and the lower right corner Ringo, the ordinary one. The resulting mix was balanced and offered something for everyone.

There is this anecdote where John asks Ringo to drum the same as on a record he heard and Ringo says, “But John, these are two guys.” After which John answers, “Don’t let that bother you.”

The Boy Next Door

Ringo, the ordinary one, unintentionally, made sure that the Beatles did not become unattainable, especially at the peak of their popularity. He was and remained the normal one, the boy next door. We can still relate to these extraordinary people, especially John and Paul, through Ringo, who just seemed to be a nice chap.

We awe him very much. Congratulations Ringo!

Peter Eijgenhuijsen

Posted on Leave a comment

Happy Birthday Ringo Starr – and Jim McCartney

Ringo Starr of The Beatles
Ringo Starr

As we continue our celebration of Ringo Starr’s birthday, Angie McCartney gives her tribute to Ringo, and her late husband, and Paul’s father, Jim McCartney, who share the same birthday.

Angie McCartney Visiting Ringo

“Shortly after we were married, we took a trip to London to visit Paul. He drove us around each of The Beatles’ houses. When we visited Ringo and Maureen, our first impression was of little Zak, playing up in his tree house.  We had a nice afternoon tea, and then Ritchie asked Uncle Jim (as he called him) if we would like a tour of the house, which we of course were delighted to do.

New Fangled Machines

“As a side note, I had been bugging Jim for a dishwasher, as we had so many visitors to Rembrandt in those days. Mike would frequently bring a gang home late at night after a Scaffold gig or some other gathering, and I would come downstairs to a sea of dishes in the morning. Jim wasn’t in favour of these “new fangled machines” as he called them. So before we set off, I mentioned this to Ritchie. When we got to their marvellous kitchen, he made a point of showing Jim their dishwasher, showing him how it all worked etc.

Angie McCartney
Angie McCartney

So later, on our way back to town in Paul’s car, Jim turned to me and said “OK, you win. You can order one from Brown’s of Chester when we get home.” I finally got a shiny new dishwasher. My pride and joy. My new toy.

Until Jim had seen Maureen’s machine, he had the impression that the dishes went round and around, a bit like a clothes washer.

Cheers.

Angie McCartney

Posted on 1 Comment

Understanding Ringo Starr’s Drumming – A Tribute

Ringo Starr playing drums with The Beatles
Understanding Ringo Starr’s Drumming Technique

Learning Ringo’s Drum Parts

Phil Kelly has been playing drums for the best part of his life, including playing in Beatles tribute bands and learning to play like Ringo. It don’t come easy!

Forty plus years later Phil has never looked back, playing with a number of Boston and local based ‘60s/’70s bands such as The Jammers, Sherman and the Waybacks, Mr. Peabody and Beatle tribute bands such as Instant Karma, BeatleTracks, and Glass Onion.

Phil Kelly
Phil Kelly

“Seemingly, all of that became clear when the camera zoomed in above John, Paul and George in the middle of ‘I Want To Hold Your Hand’. I was immediately awestruck by how easily Ringo swayed to the music behind his Ludwig Black Oyster Pearl kit. So, without even knowing his impact on the world, Ringo has inspired millions of kids just like me to pick up a set of stick and emulate every little nuisance of his playing.” 

A Lefty on a Righty

Like many drummers, attempting to emulate Ringo wasn’t as easy as it appeared. “The problem is Ringo is a left handed drummer playing a right handed kit,” said Phil, “and as a result his drum fills are counter-intuitive and difficult to reproduce exactly.” 

Kelly explained what it is like, as a drummer, and especially one who has played in a Beatles tribute band, to recreate Ringo’s drum patterns. “When a right handed drummer like myself does a drum fill around the kit, we lead with our right hand. Ringo, being a left handed drummer, leads with his dominant left hand. The end result of this unorthodox style of drumming produces a different sound because of the crossing of the left hand over the right. This nuisance is inherently Ringo’s playing style and ironically, it is what makes his drumming style challenging.

Tell Me Why

“A practical example of this uniqueness can be found when Ringo plays the opening measures to ‘Tell Me Why’. He leads with his left hand in the tumbling drum fill off the tom and snare. Later in that song, Ringo plays a measure of triplets (again leading with his left hand) that leads nicely into the final refrain and the tumbling drum fills to end the tune. The same can be said for Ringo’s drumming on ‘I Want To Hold Your Hand’. In this song, Ringo attacks the snare and tom with powerful accents, again leading with his left hand that complements the phrasing by John and Paul on the song’s title.

The Swish

“Another nuisance that was revolutionary and a very much a part of the early Beatle recording (and one that I learned early in my Beatle tribute band days) was to play the hi-hat in a slightly opened position, playing the time sequence (usually in quarter notes) in a figure eight pattern. When Ringo played this unique style, it produced a totally different sonic than playing straight up and down quarter notes. The end result is a rhythmic pattern that gives the song a swing feel and because of the slightly open positioning of the hi-hats, creates a sizzle or swishing sound. Ostensibly, Ringo’s style of hi-hat play turned the hi-hat into what sounds like a ride cymbal. Evidence of this style of hi-hat playing can best be found in ‘I Want To Hold Your Hand’, ‘Please Please Me’ and ‘All My Loving’.

Ringo’s Feel For The Song

“Ringo’s drumming is not overly technical but the strength of his drumming is his feel for the song. There are hundreds of technically superb drummers that are adept at sight reading from charts, but few have the feel for a song that Ringo possesses. Jim Keltner, the great studio drummer and long-time admirer of Ringo’s playing, said; ‘everything Ringo played had such great, deep natural feel. He’s a song drummer. Guys that sit down and they hear the song and they play appropriately for that song.’

The Relaxed Swing

“Anyone can learn how to play quarter, eights and sixteenth notes but having a feel for a song is a very special skill. I realized early on in my playing career that to accurately reproduce Ringo’s drumming style, I needed to master the use of my left hand in accentuating my fills around the kit, while focusing on that relaxed swing he brought to every note. The challenge for myself, even today, is to allow that feel to come through without rushing the tempo.

“One of the things that always amazed me about Ringo’s drumming is his ability to reproduce a nearly flawless tempo take after take. His drumming is always spot on; he never overplayed his part, and always provided exactly what the song needed. As a young drummer learning the craft, I try to model these tenets of playing into my own style.

No Beatles without Ringo

Ringo, for me, and I’m sure many others influenced by him, is the reference point used as to what a great drummer is and should be. I’ve always argued with my musical colleagues that the Beatles don’t become the Beatles without Ringo’s unique style of drumming.”

Discover more about Ringo and why he is rightly considered one of the all-time greatest drummers in Finding the Fourth Beatle.

David Bedford

Posted on Leave a comment

So I Doorstepped Ringo and Asked Him to Go For a Pint

Ringo Starr relaxing at home
Ringo Starr relaxing at home
Ringo Starr relaxing at home

David Stark recalls door-stepping Ringo one Saturday night in 1970, when he and a pal decided to ask him out for a pint. 

Finding Ringo’s House

Compton Avenue turned out to be a secluded private road situated almost opposite the entrance of Kenwood House, a former stately home on the posh side of Hampstead Heath in north London. We parked on Spaniards Road, walked a few yards to our destination street and eventually found Ringo’s house, after getting a little help from Lulu and Maurice Gibb, who also lived in the road at the time. We’d rung their bell first, not knowing which house was Ringo’s, but they kindly pointed it out to us at the end of the street, a large double-fronted house named Round Hill. 

Ringo's house in London NW3
Ringo’s house in London NW3

Ringo opened the door

There was obviously some kind of party going on judging from the cars parked in and around Ringo’s drive, but we mustered up some Dutch courage, rang the bell, then held our breath and waited. We didn’t have to wait long, as the door was opened by the famous drummer himself, casually dressed and holding a pool cue. He was obviously in the middle of a game and wondering what the hell we were doing there.

“How can I help you, lads?” he asked.

“We were just wondering if you’d like to come out for a pint,” I volunteered, feeling somewhat stupid but at least sticking to the plan.

“That’s very nice of you but I’m afraid we’ve got friends in tonight,” Ringo replied, looking rather bemused but taking it all in his stride. 

“Another time maybe,” he added.

Eric Clapton

As he said this, I suddenly spotted Eric Clapton walking through the hallway just a few feet behind him, so he wasn’t just fobbing us off. We quickly said our goodbyes as Ringo closed the door, then off we headed up the street and back to the car, laughing our silly heads off. All great fun and definitely something a bit different to do on a boring Saturday night in London.

© 2020 David Stark / This Day In Music Books

Get David’s Book Now